If a letter from the Ministry is sitting on your desk, the single most important thing to know is that there is a clock running. A proposed safety rating must be disputed in writing to the Deputy Registrar within 30 business days of receiving it. Miss that window and the rating stands, whatever the merits of your case.
Call us today on +1 (905) 486-1666. The earlier we see the file, the more options you have.
One thing to be clear on before the numbers below. Every percentage on this page is a percentage of your own threshold, not of your inspections. The Ministry sets that threshold from your fleet size and the kilometres you travel, so the same handful of violations means something different for a ten-truck fleet than for a hundred.
A warning letter. Your overall violation rate has reached roughly 35 percent of your threshold. Nothing has been taken from you yet. This is the cheapest moment to act and the one most carriers ignore.
An audit notice. At around 50 percent of threshold, the Ministry may require a facility audit, and you are obliged to take part and produce the records requested. Refusing to participate carries the same outcome as failing.
A proposed Conditional rating. This follows a failed audit, or a violation rate reaching 70 percent of threshold with or without an audit.
An interview request. Between roughly 85 and 99 percent of threshold, you may be required to meet a senior ministry official and submit an action plan, with your progress monitored afterwards.
A show cause meeting. At 100 percent of threshold or above, you may be asked to meet the Deputy Registrar and explain why you should keep your operating privileges and what you have already corrected. Suspension or cancellation is on the table at this stage.
Safety ratings and sanctions follow different routes, and confusing them costs carriers their case.
A safety rating cannot be appealed to the Licence Appeal Tribunal. The only route is a written dispute to the Deputy Registrar, within 30 business days of receiving the proposed rating. That is the whole mechanism.
A sanction is different. Fleet limitation, plate seizure, suspension and cancellation are the serious measures, and those do carry an appeal route to the Tribunal.
There is also a narrower provision worth knowing. A carrier that volunteered for an audit, failed it, but holds an overall violation rate of 50 percent of threshold or less may apply for deferred safety rating status by disputing the proposed Conditional rating.
A Conditional rating runs for a minimum of six months and is public throughout. Insurers see it at renewal. Shippers see it before awarding freight.
Getting out of it is a two-part test, and both halves must be met. Your overall violation rate has to come down to 60 percent of threshold or less, and you have to pass another facility audit. Where the Conditional rating came from a failed audit, that second audit is mandatory, not optional.
Six months is the floor, not the expected duration. Carriers who spend the first of those months arguing rather than correcting usually spend considerably longer than six.
• Read the notice and tell you exactly which clock is running and when it expires
• Order and review your abstract so we are working from what the Ministry sees
• Prepare and file the dispute where there are grounds, within the window
• Build the corrective action plan the Ministry will ask for
• Prepare you for an interview or a show cause meeting, and attend with you
• Get your records to a standard that passes the re-audit
We will not tell you an outcome is guaranteed. The Registrar decides, not us. What we can tell you quickly is whether you have grounds, what the realistic range of outcomes looks like, and what has to happen first.
Call +1 (905) 486-1666 or contact us. Bring the letter.
This page sets out the process as the Ministry publishes it, and it is not legal advice. Where a suspension or cancellation is on the table, it is worth having legal counsel alongside a compliance consultant.
How long do I have to dispute a proposed rating?
Thirty business days from receiving it, in writing, to the Deputy Registrar. This is the one deadline worth acting on today.
Can I appeal a Conditional rating to the Licence Appeal Tribunal?
No. Safety ratings go to the Deputy Registrar only. Sanctions such as suspension or plate seizure are the ones with a Tribunal route.
How long does a Conditional rating last?
Six months minimum. To be upgraded you need your violation rate at 60 percent of threshold or less and a passed facility audit. Both, not either.
Can I still get insurance with a Conditional rating?
It becomes considerably harder and more expensive. Some carriers find the market effectively closed to them at renewal, which is why the rating matters commercially long before it threatens your licence.
We have not had a notice yet, but our rate is climbing.
That is the right time to call. Everything on this page becomes cheaper and more winnable the earlier it is addressed.
Privacy Policy Compliance Mentorz SMS Consent © 2026 Compliance Mentorz. All Rights Reserved.